We don’t care. We don’t have to. We’re the MBTA.

In the words of the late, great, Irving Snyder, WA1ETG SK, I have a “tale of woe.” As always, as an employee of the fantastic Commonwealth of Massachusetts, the opinions of this website are my own and not the view of my employer or anyone else.

Late in August, I was in a rush on a Wednesday and couldn’t change my five dollar bill for ones to pay for parking. With the MBTA, they have something called an “honor box” in which you pay your $4 parking fee into a small slot numbered with your space. “No worries…” I said to myself, “…since I am in a rush, I will eat the late fee and just pay them when I get a violation notice.” A brilliant plan, correct? It was, I’ve done it before. Also, since I knew I was likely going to face the same problem on Friday I was just going to pay $10 with the Friday violation notice. This plan crashed to earth when I got the Friday violation notice:

One of these things is not like the other...

Can you spot the key difference between these two notices? According to the 8/21 notice, I have 8 outstanding violations. This is impressive, as with every violation notice previous to this, including the 8/19 notice, hasn’t included a peep about any kind of outstanding violations. So, I place an e-mail to LAZ Parking, as they suggested on their voice mail greeting, to ask them how the heck this happened. They politely provided me a spreadsheet showing that I hadn’t paid my violations numerous times since they took over.

Slight problem: I did pay them.

I’m no angel. According to the spreadsheet I had 16 violations since December 1st. However, I have been extremely thorough in paying my violations since the parking fee increase, specifically because I knew that $5/pop could add up quick. While I cannot specifically say “Oh, hey, I paid that violation on June 23rd.” (Because really, who remembers that?) There were two violations that I was sure I had paid. Also, apparently, I did possibly owe them $2.75 from a violation in December. I won’t even attempt to remember that.

So, I ask them how I can contest it? Well, simple, I just tell them which spot I parked in during those dates and they can check.

Slight problem: There is not assigned parking at the MBTA.

With the MBTA commuter rail, each spot is numbered and that’s the number you pay for. However, it’s first come first serve. Most days I usually get a spot in the between 50 and 100. But really, I now have to keep track of which spot I park in on a daily basis just in case LAZ says I didn’t pay? What? I explained this to the CSR and after following up a week later asking them if there was any movement on this she reiterated she needed the numbers.

This brings us to today.

I give up.

That’s it MBTA, you win. You’ve created a system where you can tell people they owe money and they have little to no recourse. You have a cash system, someone can have no proof they paid on random dates and in order to contest it, you make them jump through nearly impossible hoops. I give up. I am bending over and taking it.

So, now, in order to cover my ass:

  • I will be paying my outstanding fee with a check, probably hand delivered, and I will get a receipt.
  • Further violations will be paid with via a check, as suggested by LAZ, and I will be keeping the canceled checks on record.
  • After I get the canceled check, I will be following up with LAZ to make sure they credited it to my account.

Plus, just to add insult into injury halfway through the back and forth with LAZ, I get this on my windshield:

Insult to Injury

A $15 ticket because I was parking in the lot with an “outstanding balance”

Thanks, MBTA.

6 comments.

  1. Yeah, cities can get awful greedy and dense when it comes to stuff like this, knowing if they make it easy to contest, most people will, and their revenues will drop. I always there was an obvious conflict of interest in stuff like that.

  2. Tell me about it. Not only did I pay my outstanding fees with a check – nearly a week letter I get the orange ticket. When I called they had no record of my check – fortunately I did. I asked them to resolve the orange ticket and heard nothing back.

    I am very close to submitting a public records act request for all complaints concerning Laz Parking along with their contract with the MBTA.

    Somehting needs to be done

  3. If I was really interested in a prolonged battle, I would ask LAZ to prove that I had not paid. By telling me to pay my fees by dropping them off in the violations box, once I put it in there, I should have it in good faith that my fee is paid. If something happens to it once it goes into the violation box, that is not my problem.

  4. Same thing happened to me on November 11th, and I HAD put the money in the slot before getting on the train. My kids each shoved 2 bucks into the correct slot, and yet I still got one of the infamous envelopes on my windshield. How does one possibly prove that they paid, when the system involves shoving dollar bills into a slot?!? Very frustrated right now, because someone from LAZ did call me back, claiming that she “checked the photo” and there was no money in that slot, and no double payments in any other slot.

  5. P.S. Ben, I just noticed that your violation was issued only one stop away from my violation… same commuter line. Interesting.

  6. Since, Laz took over AIM, I have been told I have an outstanding Balance of $70, which I have every canceled check to prove I paid and AIM cashed.

    In addition, I rec’d one of those bright violations- I mailed my outstanding payment for one wks pymt in Feb to LAZ over 2 wks ago and they still have not received. Funny, AIM was in Providence RI and rec’d and cashed my checks w/in 3 days of my mailing. LAZ is in BRAINTREE MA and it take 3 wks for mail to leave Norwood to get to Braintree…hmmm…now to lose a days pay for a hearing to argue over the slow posting of payments-I am soooo glad I used checks and not cash! I am pretty smart, but just to clarify and I called the USPS- it takes 1-2 days for mail to go from Norwood to Braintree!

Post a comment.