Open Discussion, the Internet, and the Memory Hole

There has been a lot of drama over the ZOMG CW OPZ ROOL AND NO CODEZ DROOL Video. It started when Jeff, KE9V posted a message on Twitter linking to a weblog post at the Parma, OH Amateur Radio Club weblog. The post contained a video about the death of Morse code, and how anyone who didn’t pass a Morse code test is dumbing down the hobby.

I, like any other red-blooded netizen, posted comments on the post and the YouTube page saying in no uncertain terms on how I thought his thoughts bore a striking resemblence to a large pile of edible offal from the stomachs of various domestic animals (“a load of tripe”). I don’t think Morse is the cat’s meow, but I do know it (despite being one of the dumb no-code hams) The bile flowed from my fingertips and my circle of Hams on twitter was abuzz at the video, most of the talk being negative.

Then it was gone…

Steve, K9ZW tweeted that he couldn’t get to the video via the weblog post. Sure enough, the video had been removed. I forwarded him the YouTube link, which he replied he also couldn’t get too. Looks like someone had second thoughts. Finally, the title and all the comments were deleted from the post and all further comments needed to be moderated. All that was left was a non-functional little nubbin of a post that previously had about six people’s comments. I assumed that it was over and that the creator of the video retreated. I would have preferred some kind of discussion or an apology, but it’s his call.

Flash forward to Friday morning, where I see that the video has been reposted. I was glad I can now link to it to talk about it some more, but it did ruffle my feathers that the creator, rjkd732, essentially tossed all the previous discussion down the memory hole. About ten people commented on the various postings and he has seen fit to flush it all down the tubes. I posted my comments regarding this and reposted my original comment regarding offal. This time, he did reply saying that he took down the video because (para-phrasing here) I was being rude and calling other people names.

He then took it down again…

Then this little gem showed up in my Youtube INBOX:

those who passed code ARE BETTER! stick that in your pipe, whiner.
Awesome. I replied in a kind, polite, articulate manner:
Hahahaha!

Oh wait… You’re serious…

Let me laugh even louder….

HAHAHAHAHAHAHA!!!!!!

OK. So I’m not a saint. What?

The Internet is a great place for meeting people that say things that make your blood boil and pray for the ability to punch people via TCP/IP. I seem to have a silly habit of tilting at windmills and trying to engage them and talk. What annoys me is when people do the electronic equivalent of “taking their marbles and going home” by deleting threads and comments. Although he’s well within his rights to do these things, it sets off a giant flashing red light that says he’s not interested in hearing an alternate viewpoint.

3 comments.

  1. Wow. Just wow.

  2. I too am tired of hearing how no-coders are some kind of mental midgets.

    Is a seperate test required for packet? Or APRS? Of course not it is just a different operating mode imagine if you had to test for every mode you want to operate.

    Basicly the people who complain about this feel as if they have been diminished as a person some how. Get over it.

  3. Yeah, I’ve had the privilege of dealing with a few hams that viewed no-code techs as lesser than CB ops…

    Oddly enough, they start behaving really politely after they double click the wrong attachment in an email, and realize that the only ‘computer guy’ at the club is That Blasted No-Coder.

    ( Disclaimer: I passed a 5wpm after three attempts, and 13wpm after 1, but I didn’t take General written till after they removed code requirement. Would have taken it the day I took the 13wpm test, but they only brought Tech writtens to the VE session that day. )

Post a comment.